The Truth About Rewards and Their Impact

Rewards are often used to motivate kids, but research shows they might not be as good as we think. Experts like Alfie Kohn and Richard, who worked on Self-Determination Theory in the 1970s and 1980s¹, say rewards can harm kids’ motivation. They can also make kids feel anxious, ashamed, and controlled².

Rewards can hide real behavior and treat symptoms, not the root cause. They can make kids feel less independent and lower their self-esteem². Instead, experts suggest building strong relationships, giving kids freedom, and creating positive spaces. This helps kids develop their own motivation.

Key Takeaways

• Rewards can have unintended consequences, including decreased intrinsic motivation and increased anxiety.
• Experts recommend focusing on building relationships, autonomy, and positive environments to foster intrinsic motivation.
• Rewards can mask authentic behavior and create dependence on external validation.
• Tangible rewards without clear communication may not positively impact motivation¹.
• Rewards linked to well-defined, challenging levels of mastery can enhance self-efficacy and intrinsic motivation¹.

Understanding the Psychology Behind Reward Systems

Reward systems start with behavioral psychology. Self-Determination Theory by Richard Ryan and Edward Deci explains why we do things. It talks about intrinsic and extrinsic motivation³.

The Evolution of Reward-Based Behavior

Intrinsic motivation is doing things because they’re fun. Extrinsic motivation uses rewards to get us to act³. But, giving rewards for things we already like can make us like them less³.

Yet, rewards for doing well can make us feel more confident and interested³.

How Rewards Affect Brain Chemistry

Reinforcers are things that make us respond without learning first⁴. They can be good, making us want more, or bad, making us want less⁴. Both kinds of reinforcers change how we remember things⁴.

The Role of Motivation in Human Behavior

Feeling good or bad is linked to what happens to us⁴. Learning from these feelings is called action-outcome learning⁴. Rewards and punishments can change how we remember things⁴.

It’s important to understand how rewards work. Knowing about intrinsic and extrinsic motivation helps make better reward systems. These systems help us change our behavior for the better.

The Historical Development of Reward Systems in Education

Reward systems in education have changed a lot over time. Traditional methods⁵ used things like grades and stickers to motivate students. But, experts like Alfie Kohn have questioned their lasting impact⁵.

Too much focus on rewards can harm a student’s natural drive to learn. It can slow down skill development and increase mistakes⁵. Rewards might also take away from the real goal of education: helping students grow and learn⁵.

Today, education is moving towards encouraging students to learn for themselves. This is through ideas like autonomy, mastery, and purpose⁶. Research shows that when students are motivated from within, they do better and feel happier⁵.

The debate on using rewards in schools is ongoing. Teachers and researchers are looking at both sides of the argument⁵. They aim to find a balance that helps students succeed⁶.

The history of rewards in education shows a shift from external to internal motivation. This change is based on new findings in educational psychology and classroom management⁵. Teachers are working to create environments that foster a genuine love for learning⁶⁵.

Rewards and Their Impact on Modern Parenting

Rewards are common in parenting, but their effects are complex. Research shows rewards can boost short-term behavior but harm long-term motivation and parent-child bonds⁷.

Short-term vs. Long-term Effects

Rewards quickly get kids to comply⁷. But, they can make kids focus too much on the reward, not the task itself⁷. The more rewards, the less kids want to do things for themselves⁷. This can make them less interested in learning and more focused on doing well⁷.

Cultural Differences in Reward Systems

Parenting styles, including rewards, differ across cultures. Western cultures often use rewards to motivate, while Eastern cultures value group harmony and inner drive⁷. Knowing these differences helps parents understand rewards’ impact better⁷.

Impact on Parent-Child Relationships

Dependence on rewards can make parent-child relationships transactional, not trusting⁷. Experts say building strong relationships and encouraging kids’ inner drive is better than rewards and punishments⁷.

Understanding rewards’ effects helps parents make better choices. They can create a supportive environment for parenting, child discipline, and cultural parenting styles⁷.

“The more rewards you use, the more an individual focuses on the reward rather than the task itself. This can undermine intrinsic motivation and lead to a decline in long-term performance.”

Parents must consider rewards’ short and long-term effects in positive parenting, child discipline, and cultural parenting styles. They should aim for an environment that boosts intrinsic motivation and strengthens parent-child bonds⁷.

The Connection Between Rewards and Intrinsic Motivation

The link between rewards and intrinsic motivation is complex. Self-Determination Theory says intrinsic motivation comes from feeling free, competent, and connected⁸. But rewards can sometimes mess with these feelings, making people focus more on getting something than enjoying the activity itself⁸.

Studies show rewards’ effect on motivation varies⁹. If rewards praise someone’s skill or progress, they can boost motivation⁹. But if they feel controlling or like a goal, they can hurt a person’s freedom and drive⁸.

It’s important to use rewards wisely. They should add to, not take away from, a child’s sense of control and skill⁸. By supporting self-motivation, parents and teachers can help kids love learning and strive to do their best on their own terms⁸.

Knowing how rewards affect motivation helps parents and teachers create a supportive environment. This environment encourages curiosity, self-motivation, and a sense of autonomy and competence⁸. This approach is key for healthy growth and a lifelong love of learning⁸.

How Rewards Affect Children’s Emotional Development

Rewards can greatly affect a child’s emotional growth¹¹. They can make a child feel their worth depends on what others think¹¹. This can cause anxiety and stress if they don’t get rewards¹¹. Children might also start to rely too much on rewards to feel good¹¹.

Impact on Self-esteem

Studies show that focusing on how they do things, not just what they do, helps¹¹. Giving praise and positive feedback is key in shaping their self-worth¹². Praising specific actions is better than general praise for boosting self-esteem¹².

Anxiety and Stress Responses

Rewards motivate kids to act well by being a reward for good behavior.¹² But, too much focus on rewards can make kids anxious if they don’t get praise¹¹. Staying calm and focusing on the effort, not just the outcome, can help¹³.

Emotional Dependency Patterns

Rewards can make kids too dependent on others for feeling good about themselves¹¹. This can stop them from wanting to do things on their own¹³. Parents should give lots of praise and encouragement that fits the child’s actions and interests¹².

Knowing how rewards affect kids helps parents create a better environment. This environment supports self-esteem, resilience, and emotional health¹¹¹²¹³.

“Positive reinforcement is classified as the only type of discipline that works, according to Ira Chasnoff, M.D.”¹³

Understanding the link between rewards and kids’ emotional growth helps parents. They can build an environment that supports self-worth, resilience, and emotional health¹¹¹²¹³.

The Hidden Costs of Reward-Based Parenting

Reward systems might seem like a good way to motivate kids, but they have hidden downsides. Rewards can actually decrease intrinsic motivation, reduce creativity, and shift the focus from long-term learning to short-term gains.¹⁴ They can also make kids less likely to help others without being paid, which can hurt their social skills.

Positive discipline is a better way to teach kids. It focuses on teaching and solving problems, not just rewarding or punishing. This method helps kids learn to control themselves and find their own reasons to do things right, leading to lasting changes¹⁵. Alfie Kohn, a parenting expert, says moving away from rewards and punishments can help kids grow better in the long run.

“Rewards are not the answer. In fact, they’re part of the problem. They may get short-term compliance, but they undermine long-term motivation.”

– Alfie Kohn, author and parenting expert

Parents looking for better ways to motivate their kids should think about the downsides of rewards. By focusing on what kids want to do for themselves and using positive discipline, they can raise kids who are more well-rounded, resilient, and self-directed.

Rewards and Academic Performance

Rewards can have a big impact on how well students do in school. They might make students work harder and do better for a little while. But, they can also mess up how well students learn in the long run and how creative they can be in school¹⁶.

Some research says that rewards like points or the ‘House’ system can help students learn better over time¹⁶. But, using rewards too much can make students lose their love for learning on their own¹⁷.

Rewards can also affect how well students think creatively and solve problems. Students who get rewards for good grades might choose easier work to get more rewards. This can stop them from growing and learning how to think critically¹⁶. It’s important to make learning fun and engaging, not just about getting rewards¹⁷.

Teachers and parents should look for other ways to motivate students. By celebrating students’ achievements in many areas, not just grades, rewards can help students grow in all ways¹⁶. This way, students can feel good about themselves and explore their interests without just focusing on grades¹⁷.

The Impact of Rewards on Social Development

Rewards can greatly affect children’s social development. They might encourage good behavior in the short run. But, they can also hurt real empathy and kindness¹⁸. Kids who get rewards for sharing might share less on their own¹⁸.

Rewards can also make kids compete with each other. This can damage their friendships¹⁸.

To help kids grow socially, we should focus on why they’re kind and cooperative. It’s important to show them these values ourselves. Empathy and good social skills are vital for strong peer relationships¹⁹. By valuing kindness itself, we help kids feel the need to help others¹⁹.

“Rewards may undermine the intrinsic motivation that fosters true altruism and cooperation in children.”

The impact of rewards on kids’ social growth is complex. While they might improve some behaviors, they can harm kids’ social skills and peer relationships in the long run¹⁹. By focusing on what’s inside kids, not just rewards, we support their empathy and kindness¹⁹.

Alternative Approaches to Motivation and Encouragement

Traditional rewards might not always be the best way to motivate kids. Autonomy-supportive parenting focuses on giving choices and explaining why. This approach helps kids feel more independent and self-assured²⁰.

Building Intrinsic Motivation

Teaching kids to have a growth mindset is key. It helps them see challenges as chances to learn and grow. This mindset boosts their love for learning and confidence²⁰.

Strength-based methods also work well. They focus on what kids are naturally good at. When kids feel their strengths are valued, they dive deeper into their interests²⁰.

Positive Reinforcement Techniques

Positive reinforcement can be very helpful. It rewards effort and progress without taking away from kids’ inner drive. This way, kids feel seen and valued without needing external rewards²⁰.

Using these alternative methods, parents can help kids find their true purpose. This empowers them to reach their highest potential²⁰.

Understanding Neurodivergent Children and Reward Systems

Children with ADHD or on the autism spectrum might not react the same to rewards as others. Research shows that rewards can work for autistic, making it important for parents to find rewards that each child likes²¹. Also, autistic people might find it hard to get motivated by social rewards, showing we need more study in this area²¹.

For kids with ADHD, rewards can help if used right to improve their planning skills. Dopamine helps us seek good things, and autistic brains might see rewards differently²¹. But, we should not rely too much on rewards, as it might make kids expect them all the time and lose their natural drive. Yet, studies say rewards can be okay if used right, without hurting motivation²¹.

Autistic kids like using visual aids, like charts, to show good behavior.²¹ Making a good reward system for autistic kids means picking rewards they like, setting clear goals, and showing them the long-term benefits. Using their special interests to motivate them is also key²².

“Many therapists supporting Autistic kids often use rewards, reinforcers, and frequent praise as motivators for engaging in learning activities.”²³

Rewards can be good for neurodivergent kids, but we should not rely too much on them. We can encourage them by showing them how to do things step by step and by mixing up activities they like and don’t like²³. It’s important to tailor our approach to each child’s needs and likes to help them stay motivated and succeed in the long run.

The Role of Praise versus Tangible Rewards

Research has shown that praise can be more effective than material rewards in some cases. Studies indicate that verbal rewards can be better than material ones in certain situations²⁴. It’s important to know the different types of praise and when it might be harmful.

Different Types of Praise

Not all praise is the same. Process praise, which focuses on effort and strategies, is better than person praise. Person praise can make children believe their abilities are fixed²⁵. Process praise helps children see they can improve with hard work²⁵.

When Praise Becomes Harmful

Praise can be powerful but can also backfire if used too much or wrongly²⁵. Too much praise can make children rely on it too much and lose their motivation²⁵. Some praise, like person praise, can hurt a child’s self-esteem and make them afraid to fail²⁵.

To be effective, praise should be specific, sincere, and focus on what the child can control²⁴. If praise becomes expected or fake, it can harm a child’s self-esteem and growth mindset²⁵.

The role of praise in child development is complex. Research shows praise can help with a child’s growth mindset, self-esteem development, and effective praise. But, it’s crucial to know the different types of praise and when it can harm to ensure children do well emotionally and academically.

“Praise functions differently from tangible rewards and does not have a detrimental effect on intrinsic motivation for prosocial behavior among young children.”²⁵

By understanding praise’s nuances and using it wisely, parents and educators can create a supportive learning environment. This environment nurtures a child’s growth mindset language and supports their self-esteem development.

Creating Sustainable Motivation Without Rewards

Sustainable motivation comes from creating autonomy-supportive environments and setting meaningful goals. It also involves fostering self-directed learning. By giving choices and explaining tasks, parents and teachers help kids feel in control²⁶.

Setting goals that match personal values boosts intrinsic motivation. Kids are more likely to enjoy activities that are meaningful to them²⁷.

Encouraging self-reflection helps kids set their own standards for success. This way, they don’t need external rewards to feel good about themselves²⁷. By focusing on the joy of learning, we can build lasting motivation that doesn’t rely on rewards²⁷.

Supporting kids’ curiosity and love for learning is key. Letting them take charge of their education builds a sense of ownership²⁷. This approach helps kids become self-motivated learners, ready for success in all areas of life.

Source Links

1. Separating Fact from Fiction: The Impact of Rewards on Children’s Intrinsic Motivation — Child and Teen Solutions
2. The Risks of Rewards – Alfie Kohn
3. The Science Behind Incentives and Rewards in Shaping Positive Team Behaviors
4. Reward: What Is It? How Can It Be Inferred from Behavior? – Neurobiology of Sensation and Reward
5. The Effect of Rewards and Motivation on Student Achievement
6. The Dark Side of rewards and punishments in the classroom part I : My College
7. Does Rewarding Children Backfire?
8. Intrinsic Motivation: How Internal Rewards Drive Behavior
9. Pervasive negative effects of rewards on intrinsic motivation: The myth continues
10. Differences Between Intrinsic and Extrinsic Rewards
11. Giving Kids Rewards for Good Behavior Will Not Ruin Them
12. Praise, encouragement and rewards
13. Rewards Don’t Work – Here’s What Does
14. Six Reasons Rewards Don’t Work
15. Financial Incentives for Promoting Participation in a School-Based Parenting Program in Low-Income Communities
16. Effects Of Rewards On Students | Foundation Education
17. Impacting Student Success Through Renaissance Rewards and Relationships
18. Development of Monetary and Social Reward Processes – Scientific Reports
19. Tips for Using Rewards
20. Employee Motivation : 20 Easy Ways to Motivate Your Coworkers & Employees
21. Autism Reward System: All You Need to Know
22. Rewarding Your Child Who Has Autism, Reward System For Autistic Child — Autism Specialty Group
23. Rethinking Reinforcers for Autism – Learn Play Thrive
24. The effects of praise: Evidence-based tips for better outcomes
25. *CorpusGood_Chapter
26. How to Motivate People Toward Sustainability – Network for Business Sustainability (NBS)
27. Rethinking Motivation — Why Extrinsic Rewards Might Not Be the Answer